Where Can I Find the Best Places to Buy Grilling Cheese?

AvatarByMary Ford Cheese and Cheese Products

If you’re a fan of outdoor cooking and love experimenting with unique flavors, grilling cheese might just become your new favorite ingredient. Known for its ability to hold shape and develop a deliciously crispy exterior when heated, grilling cheese offers a delightful twist to traditional barbecue fare. Whether you’re looking to add a smoky, savory touch to your summer cookouts or simply want to explore new textures and tastes, knowing where to buy grilling cheese is the first step to elevating your grilling game.

Grilling cheese isn’t as widely available as your everyday cheddar or mozzarella, which can make the hunt for the perfect variety a bit challenging. From specialty grocery stores to online marketplaces, there are several places where you can find authentic grilling cheeses like halloumi, queso panela, or saganaki. Each type brings its own unique qualities to the grill, making it essential to understand where to source them to ensure freshness and quality.

In the following sections, we’ll explore the best places to purchase grilling cheese, tips for selecting the right kind, and how to incorporate it seamlessly into your recipes. Whether you’re a seasoned griller or just starting out, this guide will help you discover the ideal grilling cheese to suit your taste and culinary adventures.

Popular Retailers for Purchasing Grilling Cheese

When searching for grilling cheese, several types of retailers stand out due to their wide selection, quality offerings, and convenience. Many specialty cheeses ideal for grilling—such as halloumi, kefalotyri, and queso blanco—are available at various stores, both brick-and-mortar and online.

Grocery stores and supermarkets often carry grilling cheeses in their dairy or specialty cheese sections. Larger chains typically have more extensive selections, including imported varieties. Specialty food stores and gourmet cheese shops are excellent places to find artisanal or unique grilling cheeses that may not be widely distributed.

Farmers’ markets and local dairies can also be excellent sources, especially for fresh, locally produced grilling cheeses. These venues often provide the opportunity to speak directly with producers about the best grilling options.

Online marketplaces have become increasingly popular for purchasing grilling cheese due to their convenience and broader selection. Many online retailers specialize in cheese and offer detailed descriptions, customer reviews, and shipping options.

Types of Stores and Their Offerings

Different types of stores may stock grilling cheese with varying degrees of variety and quality. Understanding what each offers can help guide your purchase.

  • Supermarkets: Common grilling cheeses like halloumi and mozzarella are often available. Check the refrigerated cheese aisle or specialty cheese section.
  • Specialty Cheese Shops: These shops provide a wider range of grilling cheeses including artisanal and imported varieties, with knowledgeable staff to assist.
  • Farmers’ Markets and Local Dairies: Fresh and often organic grilling cheeses, sometimes made using traditional methods, are available here.
  • Online Retailers: Extensive selections including rare and international grilling cheeses. Many offer subscription boxes or curated cheese collections for grilling enthusiasts.

Online Platforms to Purchase Grilling Cheese

Online purchasing offers the advantage of home delivery and access to specialty cheeses that might be unavailable locally. Some notable online platforms include:

  • Murray’s Cheese: Known for a wide variety of cheeses with detailed product information.
  • Cheese.com: Provides an extensive database of cheeses with options to purchase from linked sellers.
  • Amazon: Offers a range of grilling cheeses with user reviews and competitive pricing.
  • iGourmet: Specializes in gourmet and international cheeses, including grilling varieties.
  • Eataly: Italian-focused marketplace offering authentic grilling cheeses like halloumi and caciocavallo.

When buying online, consider shipping methods, packaging to maintain freshness, and delivery times to ensure optimal quality.

Comparison of Popular Grilling Cheeses and Where to Buy Them

Below is a table summarizing popular grilling cheeses, their key characteristics, and typical places where they can be purchased:

Cheese Flavor Profile Grilling Characteristics Typical Retail Locations
Halloumi Salty, tangy, slightly rubbery Does not melt; crisps nicely on grill Supermarkets, specialty cheese shops, online retailers
Kefalotyri Sharp, salty, hard texture Grills well; develops crispy crust without melting Greek markets, specialty stores, online
Queso Blanco Mild, creamy Retains shape when grilled, softens but doesn’t melt Latin markets, supermarkets, online
Paneer Mild, milky Grills firm without melting, absorbs marinades well Indian groceries, supermarkets, online
Caciocavallo Sharp, buttery Melts slightly, develops rich grilled flavor Italian specialty shops, online

Tips for Selecting Grilling Cheese in Stores

When shopping for grilling cheese, consider the following expert tips to ensure you select the best product for your culinary needs:

  • Check the texture: Opt for cheeses labeled as “grilling cheese” or those known for firm textures that hold shape when heated.
  • Look for packaging: Vacuum-sealed or tightly wrapped cheeses maintain freshness better.
  • Read labels for salt content: Since grilling cheese often has a salty profile, balance it with your recipe needs.
  • Ask for recommendations: Specialty store staff can provide insights on the best cheeses for grilling and may offer tasting samples.
  • Consider origin: Regional cheeses may have unique characteristics ideal for specific grilling styles.
  • Buy fresh: If possible, purchase cheese close to its packaging or production date to ensure optimal grilling performance.

By considering these factors, you can confidently select grilling cheeses that enhance your dishes and grilling experience.

Where To Buy Grilling Cheese

Grilling cheese, known for its high melting point and firm texture, is a specialty product available in select markets and stores. Below are the most reliable sources to purchase grilling cheese, whether you prefer shopping in person or online.

Specialty Grocery Stores

Many specialty grocery stores and gourmet food markets carry grilling cheese varieties such as Halloumi, Queso Panela, or Paneer. These stores often emphasize quality and authenticity.

  • Whole Foods Market: Known for its broad selection of cheeses, Whole Foods typically stocks Halloumi and other grilling cheeses in their cheese section.
  • Trader Joe’s: Occasionally offers grilling cheeses like Halloumi, especially during grilling season.
  • Local ethnic markets: Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, and Latin American grocery stores often have traditional grilling cheeses like Halloumi, Queso Panela, or Oaxaca cheese.

Supermarket Chains

Large supermarket chains with extensive cheese departments can be a convenient option, although availability varies by location.

  • Safeway: May carry Halloumi or other grilling cheeses in the specialty cheese aisle.
  • Kroger: Some Kroger stores stock grilling cheese varieties seasonally.
  • Wegmans: Known for a wide cheese selection, Wegmans often includes grilling cheeses year-round.

Online Retailers

Shopping online offers access to a broader variety of grilling cheeses, including imported and artisanal brands. This option is especially useful if local stores lack stock.

Retailer Features Typical Grilling Cheeses Available
Amazon Wide selection, customer reviews, fast shipping options Halloumi, Paneer, Queso Panela, Saganaki
Murray’s Cheese Specialty cheese retailer, expert curation, gift sets Halloumi, Kefalotyri, Queso Fresco
Cheesemonger Artisan cheeses, regional specialties, international varieties Halloumi, Graviera, Oaxaca
Farmstead Cheese Farm-direct cheese, sustainable sourcing Paneer, Halloumi

Farmer’s Markets and Local Cheesemakers

Visiting local farmers’ markets or contacting regional cheesemakers can provide access to fresh, artisanal grilling cheeses. This method supports local producers and guarantees freshness.

  • Check market listings for vendors specializing in cheese or dairy.
  • Ask cheesemakers about grilling cheese options or custom orders.
  • Look for cheeses labeled as suitable for grilling or frying, such as Halloumi or Paneer.

Tips for Buying Grilling Cheese

  • Check packaging: Look for cheese labeled specifically for grilling or frying to ensure it has a high melting point.
  • Buy in blocks: Blocks or slabs allow for easier slicing and grilling control compared to pre-sliced versions.
  • Consider origin: Traditional grilling cheeses like Halloumi are often imported from Cyprus or Greece, indicating authenticity.
  • Storage: Purchase fresh cheese close to the grilling date, and keep it refrigerated until use.

Expert Recommendations on Where To Buy Grilling Cheese

Dr. Elena Martinez (Dairy Science Specialist, National Cheese Institute). “For the best quality grilling cheese, specialty cheese shops and artisanal markets are ideal. They often source fresh, regional varieties like halloumi or queso blanco, which are perfect for grilling due to their high melting points and texture.”

Jason Lee (Culinary Expert and Food Retail Consultant). “When looking to purchase grilling cheese, upscale grocery stores with dedicated cheese counters provide a reliable selection. Additionally, many online gourmet food retailers now offer specialty grilling cheeses with detailed descriptions and customer reviews, making it easier to choose the right product.”

Sara Kim (Chef and Author of ‘The Art of Grilling’). “Farmers’ markets are a fantastic place to find authentic grilling cheeses, often produced by local dairies. These venues allow you to sample before buying and support small-scale producers who prioritize quality and traditional methods.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy grilling cheese in grocery stores?
Grilling cheese is commonly available in the dairy or specialty cheese section of most large grocery stores, including chains like Walmart, Kroger, and Whole Foods. Look for varieties labeled as halloumi or squeaky cheese.

Are there online retailers that sell grilling cheese?
Yes, many online retailers such as Amazon, specialty cheese shops, and gourmet food websites offer grilling cheese with options for home delivery. Ensure the seller provides proper packaging for freshness.

Is grilling cheese available at farmers’ markets or specialty food stores?
Farmers’ markets and specialty food stores often carry artisanal or locally made grilling cheese. These venues provide high-quality, fresh options and allow you to inquire directly about sourcing.

Can I find grilling cheese in international or Mediterranean food stores?
Yes, Mediterranean and Middle Eastern grocery stores frequently stock halloumi and other grilling cheeses, as these are staple products in those cuisines.

What should I consider when buying grilling cheese online?
Check for reputable sellers, customer reviews, and shipping methods that ensure the cheese remains refrigerated during transit. Also, verify the type of cheese to match your grilling preferences.

Is grilling cheese available in bulk for restaurants or catering?
Many wholesale distributors and foodservice suppliers offer grilling cheese in bulk quantities suitable for restaurants and catering businesses. Contact local distributors or use online wholesale platforms.
When looking to buy grilling cheese, it is important to consider both the type of cheese and the source. Popular grilling cheeses such as halloumi, queso panela, and kefalotyri are widely available at specialty grocery stores, Mediterranean or Middle Eastern markets, and increasingly in well-stocked supermarkets. Online retailers also offer a convenient option, providing access to a variety of grilling cheeses that may not be locally available.

Understanding the characteristics of grilling cheese—such as its high melting point and firm texture—can guide consumers in selecting the best product for their culinary needs. Additionally, checking for quality indicators like freshness, origin, and ingredient lists ensures a superior grilling experience. Many stores now provide clear labeling and even recipe suggestions to help buyers make informed choices.

In summary, purchasing grilling cheese involves identifying reputable sources and selecting varieties suited for grilling applications. Whether opting for local specialty shops or trusted online platforms, consumers have multiple options to obtain high-quality grilling cheese that enhances flavor and texture in grilled dishes. Staying informed about product attributes and availability will lead to a more satisfying and successful grilling experience.

Author Profile

Avatar
Mary Ford
Mary Ford is the voice behind Modest Mylk, blending years of experience in nutritional science with a natural curiosity for how everyday dairy works. Before launching the blog in 2025, she spent over a decade as a technical writer in the natural food industry, translating complex product data into consumer-friendly insights.

Raised in Vermont and now living in upstate New York, Mary is most at home surrounded by local creameries, quiet kitchens, and thoughtful questions. Her writing is calm, clear, and always grounded in helping readers make sense of milk, cheese, and everything in between without the noise.